With just four weeks until Opening Day, the Boston Red Sox are gearing up for a season that could be defined by both promise and uncertainty. But here's the burning question: Who will claim the coveted No. 5 starter spot, and who will step in for Romy Gonzalez in Cincinnati? Spring training has been surprisingly smooth for the Red Sox, with no major injuries or roster controversies derailing their preparations—a welcome change for the team. However, the looming World Baseball Classic threatens to disrupt this calm, as 13 players from Boston’s 40-man roster are set to depart for the international tournament.
Manager Alex Cora recently acknowledged the evolving nature of the camp, stating, ‘It’s a different camp. It’s not that we’re 100% sure who’s going to Cincinnati, but it’s close. It’s just a matter of how we’re gonna do it.’ For now, the 26-man roster is taking shape, though late-season injuries or additional moves—like the potential addition of a left-handed reliever—could still shake things up before March 26.
Starting Pitchers: The Battle for No. 5
The first four spots in the rotation are all but locked in, with Garrett Crochet, Ranger Suárez, Sonny Gray, and Brayan Bello anchoring the staff. But the No. 5 spot remains a hotly contested position, with Johan Oviedo, Kutter Crawford, Patrick Sandoval, Connelly Early, and Payton Tolle all vying for the role. Oviedo currently holds the inside track due to his health and readiness, but his inconsistent performance—like his erratic debut on Wednesday—could open the door for others. Crawford, still recovering from knee and wrist injuries, and Sandoval, who missed the 2025 season, are both long shots to start the season in the rotation. Sandoval, however, could emerge as a left-handed bullpen option.
And this is the part most people miss: The Red Sox are comfortable starting the season with Early and Tolle in the Triple-A rotation, but a strong camp from either could force the team’s hand. Meanwhile, Tanner Houck, recovering from Tommy John surgery, won’t return until late in the season at the earliest.
Bullpen Dynamics: A Mix of Proven and Unproven Arms
Aroldis Chapman and Garrett Whitlock are locks for the back end of the bullpen, with the Red Sox expecting big contributions from Justin Slaten, Greg Weissert, and Zack Kelly as right-handed bridge options. Ryan Watson, a Rule 5 pick, will be given every opportunity to make the team due to his unique roster status. Jovani Morán, out of options, is likely to secure a spot over Tyler Samaniego, who has been slowed by a minor back injury. However, the Red Sox are still scouring the market for additional left-handed relief help, which could challenge Morán’s position.
Controversial Interpretation: Could the Red Sox be overestimating their bullpen depth? While they seem confident in their current group, the lack of a proven veteran lefty could come back to haunt them in high-pressure situations.
Infield Intrigue: Who Replaces Romy Gonzalez?
The starting infield is largely set, with Willson Contreras at first, Marcelo Mayer at second, Trevor Story at short, and Caleb Durbin at third. However, Gonzalez’s absence due to injury leaves a void that Andruw Monasterio, a versatile player on the 40-man roster, is currently favored to fill. Brendan Rodgers and Nate Eaton could challenge Monasterio with strong camps, but Rodgers’ recent shoulder injury complicates his case. Triston Casas, though nearing full strength, is expected to start the season in Triple-A to get more reps before returning to the majors.
Outfield Overload: A Talent-Rich Dilemma
The outfield is arguably the most talented yet dysfunctional area of the roster. Wilyer Abreu (right field) and Ceddanne Rafaela (center field) are locks, with Roman Anthony and Jarren Duran splitting time in left field and at DH. Masataka Yoshida remains an awkward fit, but the Red Sox may carry him as a contact-first bench bat if no trade materializes. Kristian Campbell, Nate Eaton, and Braiden Ward are on the outside looking in, with Campbell projected for Triple-A.
Thought-Provoking Question: With so much talent in the outfield, is it time for the Red Sox to make a bold trade to address other needs? Or will they continue to juggle this crowded lineup, risking player dissatisfaction and underutilization?
As the Red Sox finalize their roster, one thing is clear: this season will be a test of both depth and decision-making. Will they rise to the occasion, or will these lingering questions come back to haunt them? Only time will tell.
